The following are my comments in Steve Hays' blogpost
God Incognito. Typos corrected. Make sure to read the blogs my links refer to.
Speaking of the Synoptics...
Jesus is worshipped both before and after His resurrection
Matt. 2:11;
Matt. 14:33;
Matt. 28:17;
Luke 24:52 [cf.
John 5:23;
John 20:28;
John 9:38].
Some instances before the resurrection might plausibly be translated
"do/did obeisance" as Unitarians do, but the post-resurrection one's
seem to better be interpreted as true religious worship. Something which
would be uncharacteristic for Second Temple Jews to do if Jesus weren't
fully Divine.
Matthew's use of
"ho theos" for Jesus in
Matt. 1:23 might plausibly be teaching Christ's full deity given the rest of what Matthew says of Christ.
Matthew has
Jesus being greater than the temple (
Matt. 12:6).
How could Jesus claim to be greater than the temple when it's the
place were YHVH resides unless God resides in the body of Christ as well
[cf.
John 1:14]?
Matthew's statement that Jesus is present whenever/wherever two or three gather in His name
is an allusion to a famous passage in the Mishnah about the Shekinah glory and presence of YHVH (Mishnah, Pirke Aboth 3:2).
Both Matthew and Luke imply that
Jesus' "Wings" are YHVH's "Wings".
The
Synoptics uniformly teach Jesus' (apparently favorite)
self-indentification of being "the Son of Man". As Steve said, that has
clear divine implications as many have argued [
and which I've argued in brief in one of my blogposts].
Matthew's
concluding command to baptize in the Name [singular] of the Father and
of the Son and of the Holy Spirit suggests the Trinity.
As Steve wrote in a recent blog, to which I added my own comments in the combox.
See Dale's excellent interview with Robert Bowman. One of the things I
can complement Dale on is his great interviews. Unlike other
interviewers, Dale allows the guest to give his full comments with
little interruption. Then Dale's latter interactions often get to the
heart of the issues.
All three Synoptics quote
Isa. 40:3 and/or
Mal. 3:1 which was originally in reference to YHVH [
Mark 1:2,
3;
Matt. 3:3;
Luke 3:4;
Matt. 11:10].
Apologist Tony Costa has said that
Mark 1:1ff (esp. v. 2) alludes to
Exodus 23:20 which refers to "the angel". Specifically, Costa says
Mark 1:1ff is likely a cluster of three (3) quotations/allusion, not merely two (2). That's because
Mark 1:2 in the Greek most closely resembles
Exodus 23:20
(in the Septuagint) which refers to an angel/Angel whom God promised He
would send. If 1. Mark really is alluding to this passage in Exodus,
and 2. if that angel is The Angel of YHVH, then Mark is likely
connecting Jesus with the Angel of YHVH. If so, then that kills at least
two birds with one stone. It undermines versions of Unitarianism that
1. deny Christ's Preexistence and 2. versions of Unitarianism which
affirm Jesus is only/merely a human savior.
The "I have come" sayings of Jesus in the Synoptics is consistent with Christ's preexistence.
Though, Dale gave a link to Dunn's critique of Gathercole which made
some good points that weakened Gathercole's case [I'd link to Dunn's
book review, but I can't find the url].
All three Synoptics refer
to the blasphemy against the Holy Spirit in contrast to sins against the
Father and Son [Matthew 12; Mark 3; Luke 12]. This implies the
personality of the Holy Spirit and that the blasphemy is a sin against
Him. I've addressed this issue and how it's consistent with and hints at
the Trinity in my blogs [e.g. here, or here].
The
Synoptics teach Jesus is the bridegroom of the future church in a way
that parallel's YHVH's marriage to Israel. Since the Church is the
fulfillment of spiritual Israel, Jesus would seem to be the
eschatological fulfillment of YHVH's receiving back His divorced and/or
estranged wife.
All three Synoptics teach Jesus is the "Lord of
the Sabbath" even though one would think that only YHVH, who instituted
the sabbath, could be its Lord [Matt. 12; Mark 2Luke 6].
All three Synoptics have Jesus applying Ps. 110:1
to Himself [Matt. 22; Mark 12; Luke 20]. The Masoretic vowel pointing
of "adoni" was standardized after the beginning of the Christian era and
so may not be the correct pointing and reading [as non-Messianic Jews
would have a vested interest in pointing it "adoni" rather than
"adonai"]. But if some Christian apologists are correct that verse
5—which does have "Adonai"—interprets verse 1, then that would imply
Jesus is Adonai. See McLatchie's blogposts on Ps. 110:1 HERE and HERE.
The second link has my comments in the combox which slightly weakens
McLatchie's line of argument. But I make them for the sake of full
disclosure.
I've also got an ENTIRE BLOGPOST focused on the VERY HIGH Christology of the Gospel of Mark.
I meticulously comb through the entire gospel looking for every
possible passage that I can find where Jesus is plausibly being taught
to be YHVH. Ignore the text highlighted in yellow which I have to
seamlessly trim away in the future. Many of observations I made in
Mark can be seen in Matthew and Luke as well (sometimes amplified).
Nevertheless, the assumption of Markan Priority enhances their
authenticity and earliness in a way that GMatt and GLuke don't. Most
scholars think Mark has the lowest Christology of the four Gospels. But I
think Mark's is definitely higher than Luke, and either equal with or
higher than Matthew's. I haven't combed through Matthew like have with
Mark and Luke.
Both Matthew and Luke teach Christ to be the future eschatological Judge [e.g. Matt. 19:28; Matt. 25; Luke 22:30; cf. John 5:22].
When one would think that only the omniscient [and therefore all
fair/just] and all-authoritative YHVH would or could render such
Judgment(s).
All three Synoptics teach Jesus can forgive sins [Mark 2, Matt. 9; Luke 5]. Some/all of them refer to Jesus as the Son of Man on earth
[presumably in contrast to in heaven as in Dan. 7]. Some/all say that
the Jews thought only God could forgive sin, AND that Jesus was
blaspheming for presuming to do so.
All three Synoptics have
Jesus being explicitly [Mark & Matthew] or implicitly [Luke] charged
with blasphemy during His trial before the Jewish council and condemned
as being worthy of death. The charge most plausibly was the [alleged]
blasphemy for claiming to be on par with YHVH and to be the 2nd divine
figure in Dan. 7 who was the Son of Man [divinely] "riding the clouds".
More could be said about the high Christology of the Synoptics, but that should do as examples.
Steve wrote: In
addition, this has a counterpart in the OT. A "man" might turn out to
be an angel, while an angel might turn out to be Yahweh!
There
are many passages like that in the OT. For example, the interactions
with the Angel of YHVH or the Word of YHVH by Hagar, Manoah, Gideon,
Zechariah's vision of Joshua and the Angel, Samuel etc. In some of those
passages the entity is called the Angel of YHVH, then also called or
predicated to be YHVH a few moments later without the qualifier of "the
Angel/Messenger OF". Or it says YHVH looked or turned or had a form as
if the Angel were YHVH Himself.